NAGDCA IN ACTION

PRRL Reports

Over the past month, we have been working with our partners at EBRI on reports from our PRRL database to describe the current state of public DC plans. Three reports came out this month, and each is worth reading. The first two are focused on managed accounts and cover the use rate and employee contribution amounts compared to participants not using managed accounts. We will look at account balances in a future report.

Our findings show that take up rates for managed account products are generally low, but participants in managed accounts do tend to have higher contribution rates than the rest of the population. We were careful to be clear that our results do not imply causality. It is possible that the group of employees selecting a managed account were already more inclined to save at higher rates. However, the difference between the groups is notable, and that is information to consider as you think about different options in your plan.

The third paper examines hardship withdrawals. The use of hardship withdrawals in our sample is quite low, but for those taking them, the percentage of account balance stood out to me as the most significant aspect of the report. Many of those taking withdrawals are decimating their savings. The balance between long-term savings and short-term need is a constant struggle, and lawmakers have provided some tools to make it easier for participants to access their money, such as the $1000 withdrawal provision in SECURE 2.0.

While we have not looked at hardship withdrawals before, previous PRRL research on loans showed that participants who took loans were more likely to have credit card debt and other indicators of financial hardship. That same research also showed that much of the spending was going to essentials like health care and housing.

AZDC

I recently had the opportunity to meet with our Arizona members at the Arizona DC plans meeting, affectionately known as AZ/DC. I spoke about the new federal legislative and regulatory landscape, which I briefly touched on at our Government Member Meeting this month as well.

In case you missed those, a major focus of ours in the coming year will be educating federal legislative staff about our plans and our issues. Many staffers come into the job with little experience in the retirement industry, if any, and usually no exposure to non-ERISA plans. Our job will be to make sure they understand your needs as they consider new legislation, and those conversations will start quickly after the new year.


MEMBER CORNER

A National IRA Program

NAGDCA state auto-IRA members Hunter Railley of Colorado and Peter Thompson of Virginia recently co-wrote an important primer with the Georgetown Center for Retirement Initiatives on state-IRA programs as the foundation for a national auto-IRA program. The new Congress has several advocates for a national auto-IRA program, including Congressman Richard Neal (D, MA), who has proposed this legislation in the last several sessions.

Hunter and Peter’s paper reflects our Auto-IRA Legislative Priorities, and expands on the initial concept to provide details on how a national program could work. Their ideas will lay the foundation for our future conversations with federal lawmakers, and we will continue to build on the concept in our committee meetings this year.

Saver’s Match

I have written a lot about the Saver’s Match over the last few months, but I wanted to point out one more thing as we await the final rule from the IRS. The IRS has decided to send a letter to every person they believe could be eligible for the Saver’s Match, based on their previous tax filings. That means that several million people recently received a letter from the IRS, telling them that saving for retirement in 2027 could make them eligible for a government match.

Hopefully they opened it! For more information on the letter (known as the CP321J notice) the IRS has created this page. If you hear anything from your participants, this would be the place to direct them.


ACROSS THE INDUSTRY

Public Sector Turnover and Retention

Our friends at the National Institute for Retirement Security (NIRS) recently released an interesting report on Workforce Turnover and Retention in the Public Sector. The report is worth reading in its entirety, but one of my main takeaways is that, as with many papers we have done, it was obvious that the public sector is not a monolith. While public plans and public employees are often grouped into one mental category, differences in things like geography and job type can have a significant impact on the behaviors of different groups.

From a substantive perspective, I thought they did an excellent job of delineating between early- and late-career employees. While the public sector does have a lot of variety, one generally observable characteristic is that tenure plays a central role in employee decision making. Most of you cannot change your DB plan in response to workforce characteristics, but you can adjust your DC plan to be responsive to employee needs. The question then becomes, what is your employer’s goal and how do you use available tools to get there? This report helps provide a national context for the conversation.

BLS Data

Speaking of national level data, the BLS recently released its Economics Daily report about retirement plan access. I wanted to point it out because I do not agree with the numbers. According to their data, only 39% of state and local government employees had access to a DC plan this year, and just 20% participated. I wrote the BLS several years ago to dispute these numbers, but they stood by them, and I do not have better numbers right now to show coverage in the industry.

A goal I will put in front of our newly redesigned Industry Committee is to prove these numbers wrong.

Tokenization

A final industry report I think is worth considering relates to the tokenization of assets. Citi released a report earlier this year that analyzed the use cases for tokenizing (or digitizing) assets. To put it as simply as possible, tokenization is turning assets into digital units. Those units would be added to a blockchain and tracked through a digital ledger. They would stay on that ledger until they are withdrawn. If you want a deep dive on how it could work, the DTCC has created some helpful resources.

It is important to note that this is different from other digital assets, like Bitcoin (also known as native digital assets). Bitcoin is not backed by anything, but tokenized assets are digital representations of other things, such as real assets or a unit of stock or an ETF. Tokenizing these assets creates new opportunities, like 24/7 trading.

When I first heard about tokenization several years ago, it was almost always in the context of private market assets. The thinking was that tokenization could provide liquidity and constant trading of units of assets that are typically illiquid and hard to value on regular intervals (such as daily).

However, the Citi report focuses mostly on tokenization as the scaffolding for any kind of trading, including public assets. Blockchain based trading still has some structural hurdles to clear before it becomes a common practice, but with organizations like the New York Stock Exchange working on solutions, it likely will not be long before tokenization becomes much more mainstream. The implications for retirement plans are yet to be determined, but the developments are certainly worth watching.

All the Best,

Matthew Petersen
Executive Director, NAGDCA